New 2026 Felon Gun Rights Cases: What Williams, Bost, Hembree, Squire and Prince Mean
Federal felon-in-possession law is moving quickly. In 2026 alone, several federal appellate courts issued decisions that matter directly to people researching firearm-rights restoration after a conviction.
The important lesson is not that “felons can now own guns.” That is wrong. The more accurate lesson is that the offense, the person’s record, the federal circuit, and the available restoration path now matter more than ever.
If you are trying to determine whether your record fits the current federal or state landscape, start with the Felon Justice Eligibility Review and compare your jurisdiction in our 2026 federal circuit guide.
Why these 2026 cases matter for firearm-rights restoration
Section 922(g)(1) generally prohibits firearm possession by a person convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year. But after Bruen and Rahimi, federal courts have increasingly been asked whether that prohibition is constitutional as applied to particular people.
At the same time, DOJ has revived the administrative relief process under 18 U.S.C. § 925(c). That means some people now have two very different concepts to evaluate with counsel:
- Administrative restoration: apply to DOJ for individualized federal firearm-rights relief under § 925(c).
- Constitutional litigation: challenge § 922(g)(1) as unconstitutional as applied to the person’s particular conviction and circumstances.
Those paths are not interchangeable, and neither should be attempted based only on a headline. A federal court win in one circuit does not automatically restore another person’s rights in another state or circuit.
Third Circuit: Williams and Bost draw an important line
Edward Williams v. Attorney General — nonviolent DUI predicate
On October 13, 2026, the en banc Third Circuit affirmed relief for Edward Williams, whose federal firearm prohibition arose from a Pennsylvania DUI conviction punishable by more than one year. The court held § 922(g)(1) unconstitutional as applied to Williams.
The decision is significant because the court rejected the idea that the felony label alone permanently resolves the Second Amendment question. For people with old, nonviolent convictions, Williams is now one of the most important appellate decisions in the country.
Read the Third Circuit’s Williams opinion →
United States v. Bost — violent predicate and dangerousness
The same court decided United States v. Bost on the same day. Bost’s predicate history included terroristic threats and conduct the court viewed as demonstrating a risk of physical violence. The Third Circuit upheld § 922(g)(1) as applied to him.
Taken together, Williams and Bost show why a meaningful review must look beyond the word “felony.” A nonviolent DUI predicate and a conviction involving threats of violence do not receive the same analysis.
Bost is also directly relevant to restoration because the court discussed the revived § 925(c) process. The majority held that Bost did not have to exhaust that administrative remedy before raising a constitutional defense in his criminal prosecution.
Read the Third Circuit’s Bost opinion →
Fifth Circuit: simple drug possession has produced major as-applied wins
United States v. Hembree
In January 2026, the Fifth Circuit reversed a § 922(g)(1) conviction where the predicate felony was possession of methamphetamine. The court held the federal prohibition unconstitutional as applied to Hembree.
The Fifth Circuit emphasized that simply classifying conduct as a felony does not end the historical analysis. For restoration screening, this is especially important for people whose only predicate is simple possession rather than drug trafficking.
Read the Fifth Circuit’s Hembree opinion →
United States v. Luna
In August 2026, a Fifth Circuit panel applied Hembree in another simple-possession case. Because the government had not properly placed alleged trafficking facts before the district court at the relevant time, the appellate court treated the predicate as simple possession and left the dismissal intact on that record.
Luna reinforces a broader point: in some circuits, the exact predicate offense and the admissible record surrounding it can materially change the constitutional analysis.
Fifth Circuit: drug trafficking remains a very different category
United States v. Squire
The Fifth Circuit reached the opposite result for Curtis Squire, whose record included multiple drug-trafficking convictions. The panel held that historical tradition supported disarming convicted drug traffickers based on dangerousness and upheld his § 922(g)(1) conviction.
But Squire is not finished. The Fifth Circuit has granted rehearing en banc, with the court announcing that the case will be reheard during its January 2027 en banc session.
That makes Squire one of the cases to watch closely. Until the en banc court issues a new decision, Fifth Circuit panels continue applying existing circuit precedent.
Read the Squire panel opinion →
October 28, 2026: United States v. Cook confirms current Fifth Circuit law still controls
On October 28, 2026, another Fifth Circuit panel declined a request to hold a § 922(g)(1) appeal while Squire is awaiting en banc rehearing. The court explained that existing precedent remains binding unless and until an intervening Supreme Court decision or a new en banc decision changes the law.
For applicants and lawyers, that is an important timing point: the grant of en banc rehearing in Squire does not itself erase current Fifth Circuit precedent.
Seventh Circuit: Prince rejects a facial attack but leaves a narrower question open
In United States v. Glen Prince, decided April 2, 2026, the Seventh Circuit reversed a district court decision that had declared § 922(g)(1) facially unconstitutional.
Prince had prior armed-robbery and aggravated-battery convictions, and the conduct leading to the new prosecution involved alleged firearm use during robberies on public transit. The Seventh Circuit concluded that § 922(g)(1) plainly has constitutional applications and therefore cannot be invalidated across the board.
Importantly, the court did not decide that every as-applied challenge must fail. It expressly reserved the question for people whose convictions do not suggest that firearm possession would be dangerous in their hands.
Read United States v. Prince →
What is the emerging rule?
There is no single national rule yet, but several themes are becoming clearer:
- Violence matters. Convictions involving violence, threats, or dangerous firearm misuse are receiving much less favorable treatment.
- Drug trafficking is being treated differently from simple possession. Fifth Circuit cases illustrate that distinction particularly clearly.
- The felony label alone is under greater scrutiny in some circuits. Courts including the Third and Fifth Circuits have rejected an analysis that stops merely because an offense was classified as a felony.
- Facial challenges remain difficult. Courts can uphold § 922(g)(1) generally while still leaving room for individualized as-applied challenges.
- The circuit matters. A theory available in Pennsylvania, Texas, or Mississippi may not be available on the same terms in another federal circuit.
See our Federal Circuits and Felon Gun Rights comparison for the broader national landscape.
Does a favorable court case mean my gun rights are restored?
No. A published decision about someone else’s conviction is not permission for you to possess, buy, receive, transport, or handle a firearm.
A person still needs a case-specific analysis of:
- the exact conviction and maximum possible sentence;
- the jurisdiction where the conviction occurred;
- the person’s current federal circuit;
- whether civil rights were restored, the conviction was pardoned, set aside, or expunged;
- any remaining state firearm prohibition;
- the person’s complete later record; and
- whether § 925(c), litigation, state relief, or another legal path is actually available.
For state-specific issues, use the Gun Rights by State directory.
How does the revived § 925(c) process change the strategy?
The renewed federal restoration program gives qualifying applicants a practical administrative path that did not function for decades. That may be especially important where circuit precedent is unfavorable, unsettled, or still changing.
At the same time, the new court decisions matter because they may affect how counsel evaluates the strength of an as-applied constitutional claim, the importance of the predicate offense, and whether litigation should even be considered.
DOJ’s public rollout is scheduled to open to the first 5,000 public applicants on November 4, 2026. See our November 4 FFRR portal-opening guide, review the federal required-document checklist, and understand the DOJ presumptive disqualifiers before assuming that an application is ready.
Check Eligibility → Review Service Options →
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Third Circuit say all nonviolent felons can possess firearms?
No. Williams was an as-applied decision involving a particular DUI predicate and record. It does not create automatic firearm eligibility for every person with a nonviolent conviction.
What is the difference between Williams and Bost?
Williams involved an old DUI predicate and resulted in an as-applied Second Amendment win. Bost involved a conviction for terroristic threats and a record the court considered indicative of physical danger, so the court upheld disarmament.
Does Hembree mean a drug felony can no longer support § 922(g)(1)?
No. Hembree involved simple drug possession. The Fifth Circuit has separately treated drug trafficking as a dangerous category that can support disarmament.
What is happening with United States v. Squire?
The Fifth Circuit panel upheld § 922(g)(1) as applied to Squire’s drug-trafficking predicates, but the court has granted rehearing en banc. The Fifth Circuit announced that the en banc rehearing will occur during its January 2027 session.
Did Prince hold that § 922(g)(1) is always constitutional?
No. The Seventh Circuit rejected a facial challenge and upheld the statute’s general validity. It expressly left open some as-applied questions involving people whose convictions do not suggest dangerousness.
Should I file a lawsuit instead of applying under § 925(c)?
Not based on an article alone. The administrative and litigation paths have different standards, costs, risks, timing, and jurisdictional issues. A lawyer should review the predicate conviction, circuit law, state restrictions, sentence completion, later conduct, and available federal relief before choosing a strategy.
Can I possess a firearm while a restoration application or court challenge is pending?
No. A pending application or lawsuit is not a restoration of rights. A person should not possess or acquire a firearm unless and until the applicable prohibition has actually been removed and any separate state restrictions have been resolved.
This article provides general educational information and is not legal advice. Firearm laws and court precedent change quickly. Do not rely on this article as authorization to possess, purchase, receive, transport, or handle a firearm.
Want the next question answered for your record?
Send the conviction, jurisdiction, sentence-completion date and goal.




